eHarmony vs Christian Mingle: Which dating site is better for Christians?

Written by: John Branson
Published on:

If you’re a Christian single looking for a partner, you might have come across two dating websites: Christian Mingle and eHarmony. Both sites are geared towards helping singles find a meaningful relationship, but they differ in their approach and target audience.

Christian Mingle is a dating site exclusively for Christian singles who are looking for love and marriage. The site has been around for more than a decade and has established itself as a trusted and reputable platform for Christian dating. It has a user-friendly design and a strong emphasis on Christian values and beliefs.

On the other hand, eHarmony is a more general dating site that caters to singles of all faiths and backgrounds. It uses a unique matching system based on a 29-dimension compatibility quiz, which aims to help singles find compatible partners who share similar values, beliefs, and personalities. While eHarmony is not exclusively Christian, it does have a significant Christian user base and offers a Christian dating category.

Comparing Features of Christian Mingle vs eHarmony

When it comes to choosing between Christian Mingle and eHarmony, there are several factors that one might want to consider. Let’s take a closer look at the features of these two dating platforms.

User Base

Christian Mingle caters specifically to singles who are looking for a partner who shares their faith, particularly those who identify as Christians. On the other hand, eHarmony has a broader user base, with users of all faiths and backgrounds.

Compatibility Tests

eHarmony is known for its comprehensive personality profile and compatibility test. The test includes over 80 questions designed to measure various aspects of a person’s personality and preferences. In contrast, Christian Mingle’s compatibility test is relatively short and focuses mainly on religious beliefs and practices.

Communication Tools

Both eHarmony and Christian Mingle offer various communication tools for their users. eHarmony has a guided communication process, which helps users get to know each other in a structured way. Christian Mingle, on the other hand, offers traditional messaging and chat features.


In terms of pricing, Christian Mingle and eHarmony are similar. Both platforms offer free basic accounts, but users need a paid subscription to access more advanced features, such as messaging and viewing photos.

Mobile Apps

Both Christian Mingle and eHarmony have mobile apps available for users to download. The Christian Mingle app has a simple layout and is easy to use. Meanwhile, the eHarmony app features a more comprehensive layout, which might take some time to navigate.

In conclusion, choosing between Christian Mingle and eHarmony ultimately depends on personal preferences. Christian Mingle is an excellent choice for Christians who are looking to connect with like-minded individuals, whereas eHarmony offers a broader user base and a more comprehensive personality test.

Member Demographics

When it comes to online dating, understanding a site’s member demographics is important. Here, we will take a look at the demographics of both eHarmony and Christian Mingle.

eHarmony Member Demographics

eHarmony is known for its dedication to finding long-term relationships, which is reflected in its member demographics. The site has a large pool of members, with over 10 million active users, and a fairly even split between genders. About 48% of members are men, while 52% are women.

Additionally, the majority of eHarmony’s users are between the ages of 25 and 34, making up around 28% of the site’s members. However, users over the age of 50 also make up a significant percentage of the site’s user base at 31%.

Christian Mingle Member Demographics

Christian Mingle is a faith-based dating site focused on helping Christian singles find their perfect match. Unsurprisingly, the majority of Christian Mingle’s members identify as Christian and are looking for a partner who shares their beliefs.

Christian Mingle has a smaller pool of members compared to eHarmony, with about 6 million active users. The gender split is also fairly even, with around 44% of members being male and 56% female.

The age range of Christian Mingle users is more focused, with the majority falling between 25 and 34 years old, comprising about 34% of the site’s members. However, the site also attracts older users, with 28% of members being over the age of 50.

When it comes to ethnicity, eHarmony is more diverse than Christian Mingle. EHarmony has a larger African American, Hispanic, and Asian member base compared to Christian Mingle, which tends to attract mostly white members.

Overall, the member demographics of eHarmony and Christian Mingle differ slightly, with eHarmony having a larger and more diverse user base, while Christian Mingle attracts mostly Christian singles.

Success Stories

Christian Mingle and eHarmony are both popular dating websites, but they cater to different audiences. Christian Mingle is ideal for Christians looking to find a partner who shares the same religious beliefs, while eHarmony is geared towards individuals who are seeking a serious and long-lasting relationship. Both sites have success stories to share, and here are a few examples:

Christian Mingle

  • Daniel and Andrea had both been members of Christian Mingle for a few months before they matched. They shared a love of Christian music and conversations about faith, and after messaging on the site, they decided to meet in person. Two years later, they’re now happily married and serving in their local church.
  • For Brad and Ashley, it was love at first click. They didn’t waste any time messaging and talking on the phone before meeting up in person. Now, they’re happily married and have a beautiful daughter together.


  • After several failed relationships, Kathy decided to try eHarmony. She was matched with Bill, and they hit it off right away. They discovered they both loved hiking and exploring new places, and soon found themselves planning weekend trips together. Today, they are happily married and continue to explore the world together.
  • Derek had tried other dating sites before joining eHarmony, but kept hitting dead ends. However, that changed when he met Sarah. They bonded over their love of cooking and traveling, and the conversation never stopped flowing. Fast forward a few years later, and they’re now a happily married couple.

These are just a few examples of success stories from Christian Mingle and eHarmony. While the sites have different approaches in matching couples, both can help singles find meaningful relationships.

Pricing Plans

When it comes to choosing a dating website, pricing is a factor that can’t be overlooked. In this section, I’ll compare the pricing plans of eHarmony and Christian Mingle to help you decide which one is a better fit for your budget.

eHarmony Pricing

eHarmony offers three pricing plans: Basic, Premium, and Premium Extra. The Basic plan is the most affordable option at $59.95 per month, but it comes with limited features and communication tools. The Premium plan costs $35.90 per month for a 6-month subscription, and provides a more comprehensive experience with extra features like the ability to see who’s checked out your profile.

For those who want to take advantage of all the features and communication tools that eHarmony has to offer, the Premium Extra plan is the way to go. It costs $60.90 per month for a 6-month subscription and includes everything from the Premium plan, plus extra profile visibility and a detailed personality profile.

Christian Mingle Pricing

Christian Mingle offers two pricing plans: Standard and Premium. The Standard plan is free and allows you to create a profile, browse other profiles, and receive matches. However, you can’t initiate communication with other members unless you upgrade to the Premium plan.

The Premium plan costs $49.99 per month, or as low as $14.99 per month with a 6-month subscription. This plan unlocks all the communication features of the website, including messaging, live chat and the ability to see when other members have read your messages.


When it comes to pricing, Christian Mingle offers a free option and lower prices overall. However, if you are looking for a more comprehensive and detailed online dating experience, eHarmony may be worth the extra investment. In the end, it’s up to you to decide which online dating website is right for your needs and budget.

After considering all the important factors, it’s clear that both Christian Mingle and eHarmony are excellent dating websites that cater to specific groups of people. While Christian Mingle is ideal for Christians looking for like-minded individuals, eHarmony is a great choice for those who are particular about compatibility and long-term relationships.

If religion plays a significant role in your life and you’re looking for a partner who shares your beliefs, Christian Mingle is undoubtedly the right platform for you. With millions of registered users, you’re guaranteed to find someone who meets your preferences.

On the other hand, if compatibility and a long-term relationship are your top priorities, eHarmony’s advanced compatibility matching system can help you find a partner with whom you can build a fulfilling life.

Overall, the decision between Christian Mingle and eHarmony depends on your personal preferences, goals, and values. So, take the time to research and compare both platforms before making a choice. Remember to take into consideration the features, pricing, user base, and success rates of each site. In the end, only you can decide which dating site is the best fit for you.